...And the winner is:

Rootbeer, Bag of Salad, Chips Ahoy Cookies (with m&m's)

That's what I decided to take to the family in my ward that just had a baby. Don't worry, I was "buddied-up" with another sister in the ward and she made some sort of chicken and rice casserole.

Thanks for all the advice. FYI-If I had to do the main dish it would have been pizza :)